The team was originally assembled by the PIT's ensemble committee on January 10th, 2011. Members has recently been shuffled from previous Pit House Teams Senator, Darling, and Zoltar: The Future Telling Machine. Lucas Zachary Hazlett and Micah Sherman were new House Team Members when the team was created.
Their first show took place on January 12th, 2011 to a sold out audience at The Peoples Improv Theater.
The name Stranger is a direct pull from the first show the team performed together, when they were still unnamed. In the show, the first group game involved a drunk Billy Joel trying to record his 1977 album "The Stranger", but he and his band were too drunk to play their instruments.
On Saturday, June 25th, 2011, Stranger filled in for Big Black Car on their 8pm showcase. To date, Stranger, Big Black Car and The Baldwins are the only PIT-developed talent to perform in this featured showcase timeslot.
- Lucas Zachary Hazlett is a member of Noboby's Token, Herschel, and Mr. and Mrs. Bruce Vein. He hosts Study Hall.
- Erick Hellwig is a member of Herschel, Darling, and American Human. He hosts New Team Lunacy.
- Bradford Jordan is a member of Swords, and formerly Party Lights and Senator.
- Chris Roberti is a member of New Excitement, and formerly Halfbear and Senator. He hosts Recess.
- Micah Sherman performs in The Scene.
- Rob Stern hosts Overload The Machine, and was formerly a member of Party Lights and Senator.
- Michelle Wolf hosts Fresh, and was formerly a member of Zoltar:The Future Telling Machine and Lethal Kitty!
- Phil Wells is a member of SidViscous!, and formerly Senator.